Total Pageviews

Thursday, December 27, 2018

Solar Power and Wind Power = Two Intermittent, Low Efficiency Losers !

Solar energy is used for:
(1) 
Home and workplace heating, 

(2)
Conversion of solar heat 
into electricity, and 

(3)
Direct conversion of sunlight 
to electricity by using
photovoltaic (PV) cells. 

Most of the emphasis 
in recent decades
has been on PV cells.

Module (aka; solar panel) 
efficiency for PV cells 
has improved a lot 
since 1975.

Efficiencies 
approaching 50%
have been obtained 
for very small, 
very expensive cells. 

But for 
large-scale 
photovoltaics, 
the efficiency
tends to be 
about 15%,
and has not 
improved much 
over time.




The electricity 
generated 
by PV cells 
must be converted 
from 
direct current (DC), 
to 
alternating current (AC) 
before household use, 
resulting in a loss of energy.

PV cell efficiency in 2016 
averaged about 15%, 
and conversion 
to grid AC voltage 
was about 80%, 
making an 
overall efficiency 
of only 12%. 





Wind turbines 
extract 
kinetic energy 
from the wind. 

Wind turbines 
rotate slowly, 
but the tips 
of the blades 
move rapidly. 

The wing tip speed 
is a multiple 
of the wind speed, 
regardless of the 
rotor diameter. 

Electricity 
generators 
work best 
at high 
rotation rate, 
typically 
hundreds 
to thousands 
of revolutions 
per minute (RPM).

Gearboxes 
are required 
to convert 
the slow rotation 
of turbine rotors 
into the high RPM 
of the generators. 

The power produced 
by the wind turbine 
is proportional 
to the area swept 
by the rotors: 
  If you double 
the diameter
of the rotor,
you quadruple 
the power. 

Unfortunately, the
power generated 
by a wind turbine 
varies dramatically 
with wind speed. 




Due to the nature 
of wind and sunlight, 
wind turbines and 
solar PV cells 
produce varying,
intermittent power.

Wind turbines 
and solar 
photovoltaic cells 
can't produce 
a steady stream 
of energy into 
an electric grid,
and sometimes 
they produce 
no power at all 
for hours, 
days, or 
even weeks. 




PV cell output drops 
when clouds, 
rain, or dust 
reduce the amount 
of sunlight 
reaching the 
solar panel, 
especially 
during seasons 
that tend to be 
cloudy or rainy, 
... and every night !

Actual solar 
energy production ,
in southeastern 
Australia 
on a typical 
June 2018 day,
had high levels 
of variability 
in daylight hours, 
and zero power 
production 
at night.


Actual wind 
energy production ,
in southeastern 
Australia 
on a typical 
June 2018 day,
was even 
more volatile:
 Turbines were 
constantly ramping 
up and down, 
from 100% to 0% 
often changing a lot
in just minutes.

In many 
countries, 
calm wind
periods 
sometimes 
last longer 
than a week. 




Energy can be stored as:
(1)
Chemical energy in batteries, 

(2)
Gravitational potential energy 
behind dams, and 

(3) 
As heat, typically heated water. 




Without back-up 
supplied by 
fossil fuel 
power plants,
a 'renewables-only' 
energy system 
would require 
a vast amount 
of energy storage. 

The only technology
available today is
pumped storage 
hydropower. 

An installation 
consists of 
a lower lake, 
and an 
upper lake,
300 to 800 meters 
above the 
lower lake. 

The two lakes 
are connected by 
a pipeline, with 
a power station 
at the lower lake.

The power station
is used to
pump water uphill,
from the lower lake 
to the upper lake.

Then the 
power station  
can generate 
electric power 
from water 
flowing downhill
from the upper lake
to the lower lake.

Conventional pumped 
hydro power stations 
typically store water
for 6 to 10 hours, 
and typically 
generate electricity 
during the morning 
and evening peak 
demand periods.

A large quantity 
of water has to be 
pumped uphill 
to the upper lake, 
using expensive 
wind and solar power, 
held there for 
hours, days, 
weeks or months, 
and then released
to flow downhill, 
to generate 
electricity, 
( with an overall 
efficiency loss 
of about 20%. )