Total Pageviews

Wednesday, March 25, 2020

Very little progress on understanding the greenhouse effect since 1861

John Tyndall was an 
Irish experimental physicist 
noted for work in magnetism 
and diamagnetic polarity. 

He was a pioneer 
in infrared radiation.

He invented 
a differential 
spectrometer 
to detect 
the absorption 
of heat ,
by small quantities 
of gases held 
in a sample tube. 

He measured the relative 
infrared absorptive powers 
of gases such as nitrogen, 
oxygen, water vapor, 
carbon dioxide, ozone, 
methane, etc. 

Others had explored 
the idea of the
greenhouse effect, 
that solar radiation 
can pass 
through gases, 
but part 
of the radiation 
from the earth 
back to space, 
is absorbed. 

It was Tyndall’s 
experiments 
that gave the ideas 
needed experimental 
validity.

Tyndall recognized 
the differences in 
infrared absorption 
properties between 
dry air and moist air. 

In 1861 Tyndall gave 
an important paper
 “On the absorption 
and radiation of heat 
by gases and vapours” 
to the Royal Society 
which many consider 
as the founding 
of climate science:
“Aqueous vapor 
( water vapor ) 
is a blanket, 
more necessary 
to the vegetable life 
of England than 
clothing is to man. 

Remove for a single 
summer-night 
the aqueous vapor 
from the air which 
overspreads 
this country,
and you would 
assuredly destroy 
every plant capable 
of being destroyed 
by a freezing 
temperature. 

The warmth of our fields 
and gardens would pour 
itself unrequited into space, 
and the sun would rise 
upon an island held fast 
in the iron grip of frost.” 
– John Tyndall 
(Heat: A Mode of Motion, 1861)



In 1896, 
Swedish chemist 
Svante Arrhenius
made precise 
calculations, 
but ten years later 
recognized the 
calculations 
were erroneous 
after reviewing 
Tyndall’s 
1861 paper.

The claim 
by scientists 
at NASA-GISS, 
that carbon dioxide 
is the control knob 
of the earth’s climate,
is contradicted
by measurements.