Total Pageviews

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Thompson et al. (2019) -- Higher CO2-induced plant protein declines are grossly overstated, and easily avoided

Thompson, M., Gamage, D., 
Ratnasekera, D., Perera, A., 
Martin, A. and Seneweera, S. 

2019

Effect of elevated carbon dioxide 
on plant biomass and grain protein 
concentration differs across bread, 
durum and synthetic hexaploid 
wheat genotypes. 

Journal of Cereal Science 87: 103-110.



NOTE:
Wheat is a key food crop
throughout the world. 

Thompson et al. (2019) 
examined the biomass 
and grain protein 
concentration 
of 19 different 
wheat genotypes 
in response to 
elevated levels 
of atmospheric 
carbon dioxide.

Fears:
Rising CO2 will 
increase crop yields, 
but the harvested food 
will be less nutritious. 

Facts:
Nearly one-third 
of genotypes 
do NOT exhibit 
declining protein 
concentrations 
at higher levels 
of CO2. 

One genotype, 
called Tjilkuri, 
had a +33.1% 
protein increase!



SUMMARY:
The great 
CO2-induced 
nutrition scare 
can be overcome 
by identifying 
plant genotypes 
that do not 
experience 
protein and other 
macro and micro 
nutrient declines and 
then growing them. 

There is no 
compelling reason 
to be concerned 
about future food 
nutritional security 
of the planet.



DETAILS:
The study 
was conducted in an 
environmentally-controlled 
glasshouse at the University 
of Southern Queensland, 
Toowoomba, Queensland, 
Australia, in 2014. 

The 19 genotypes were:
5 tetraploid durum wheats, 
11 hexaploid bread wheats, and 
3 synthetic hexaploid wheats.

They were grown in pots 
and subjected to CO2 
concentrations 
of either 389 (ambient) 
or 700 (elevated) ppm. 

At maturity, the authors 
analyzed the biomass 
and protein content 
of each genotype.


Figure 1:
Grain biomass gains 
ranged from +5% to +89%
           (average of +48%) 
among various genotypes 
from a 311 ppm increase 
in atmospheric CO2:


Figure 2. 
8 of the 19 genotypes 
experienced an increase 
in total protein content 
and 6 experienced
an increase in grain 
protein concentration,
among various genotypes 
from a 311 ppm increase 
in atmospheric CO2: