Total Pageviews

Saturday, September 7, 2019

Lysenkoism in the U.S.S.R. -- politics and science

"Lysenkoism was a 
political campaign 
conducted by 
Trofim Lysenko, 
his followers and 
Soviet authorities 
against genetics and 
science-based 
griculture." ****

In the Soviet Union,
Lysenko was opposed 
by classical geneticists, 
including Nikolai Vavilov.

Vavilov had 
a global reputation 
for his system 
of banking seeds 
as genetic material.

Vavilov was arrested 
in 1940, and died in prison
about two years later).

"More than 3,000 
mainstream biologists 
were fired or even 
sent to prison,
and numerous 
scientists were 
executed as part 
of a campaign 
instigated 
by Lysenko 
to suppress 
his scientific 
opponents." ****

In August 1948, Lysenko told
a meeting of Soviet agricultural 
scientists that Stalin had
endorsed his environmentalist 
(mis)understanding of heredity. 

Lysenko and his cronies were 
advanced, extbooks were 
rewritten, and the 
geneticists were fired. 

U.S. observers 
were horrified 
when they 
learned of this
political 
intervention 
into science.

By the late 1940s, 
the absence of 
scientific freedom 
was being called 
"Lysenkoism.” 

Soviet Union science 
was transformed 
into a propaganda tool.

The Americans, unlike the 
Lysenko-dominated Soviets, 
wanted to be represented 
as beacons of free inquiry.



Contemporary science
can be very expensive. 

All scientists recognize 
that financial support 
is essential for science.

"Strings" attached to that 
money could compromise 
research objectivity.



An assertion that 
“science is political” 
is an attack on science,
because it implies
a political connection
to the reliability of the 
knowledge it produces. 

Funding can at least
steer science toward the 
subject matter desired,
if not the rsults.

Climate scientists who desire
additional funding for their
next study related to climate,
may not find any if they
had said anything good
about CO2 in their first study.

Government funding 
of climate science 
makes climate science political.