Total Pageviews

Monday, May 11, 2020

Dong et al. (2020) -- Meta-analysis-- Improved vegetable growth from CO2 enrichment averaged +34%, based on 8,877 observations

Dong, J., Gruda, N., 
Li, X., Tang, Y., Zhang, P. 
and Duan, Z. 

2020. 

Sustainable 
vegetable production 
under changing climate: 
The impact of elevated CO2 
on yield of vegetables and 
the interactions with 
environments-A review. 

Journal of Cleaner Production 
253: 119920.



NOTE:
Dong et al. (2020) say
"A comprehensive literature review
is urgently required to shed light 
on the effects of elevated CO2 
on yield and yield components 
of vegetables" .



SUMMARY:
Rising CO2 stimulates 
food crop productivities 
and yields.

The grand mean for
all vegetable types 
was a CO2-induced 
increase of +34% 
based on 8,877 
observations. 

Means of fruit, flower, 
leafy, stem and 
root vegetable types 
were of similar 
magnitude, increasing 
by 30%, 40%, 38%, 46% 
and 35%, respectively. 

Elevated CO2 increased 
the harvest index by 23%
 and the root/shoot biomass 
ratio by 8%. 

The increase 
in vegetable yield, 
was mainly 
associated with 
a CO2-induced increase 
in vegetable organ number
(32%) and mass (11%), 
although fruit mass 
increases (10%) 
played a role as well.



DETAILS:
Using the 
Web of Knowledge, 
ScienceDirect and 
Google Scholar 
databases,
the six scientists 
conducted a 
comprehensive 
literature search 
for articles examining
 the impacts of CO2 
on vegetables. 

The resultant search 
identified 107 references 
between the years 
1964 and 2018. 

The average ambient 
CO2 concentration 
was 350 ppm 
( range between 
200 and 500 ppm
whereas the 
enriched CO2 
concentration 
averaged 827 ppm 
( range between 
346 and 1200 ppm . 


Dong et al. also 
evaluated the response 
of the vegetables 
to elevated CO2 under 
aboveground (ozone, 
temperature and light) 
or below ground 
(water, salinity, nitrogen 
availability and form) 
growth-limiting 
conditions. 

They report that 
"increments in vegetable yield 
tended to be greater 
[under environmental stresses] 
compared to the lack of 
environmental stresses," 
        adding that 
"elevated CO2 counteracts 
some of the constraints 
in yield increases 
from elevated ozone 
and heat stress," 
whereas it did not 
improve yield under 
drought stress 
(compared to 
well-watered 
conditions).



CHART  BELOW:
Effect of elevated CO2 
on yield of different 
vegetable types 
( fruit, flower, leafy, stem 
and root ) and all types 
combined ( All Vegetables ). 

Data are means 
of percent change 
(relative to ambient 
CO2 conditions) 
with 95% confidence 
intervals (indicated 
with error bars). 

The total number 
of observations
in each vegetable 
category are 
in parentheses.