"Ultimately the debate on climate change will be settled not by rhetorical excess or quantity of funding. It will be settled by evidence."

Source:

https://climatediscussionnexus.com/2021/07/07/this-eventually-in-tortoise-beats-hare/

"As so often in public policy, confusion and abuse seemed to get out of the gate with frightening speed.

But ultimately it will be the tendency of the planet to become uninhabitably hot and stormy, or not to do so, that will decide the matter.

Just as the Berlin Wall fell because freedom is stronger than tyranny, and when it fell it was shown beyond rational doubt to have been a prison gate, as the West claimed, and not a defensive fortification as Soviet Communism and its apologists maintained.

Which brings us to California.

Not because it has been taken over by communists or their postmodern cousins, although there are some worrying signs.

But because one of those worrying signs is that blackouts loom as electricity prices go nuts.

So one thing plodding awkwardly across the finish line in the climate debate is that renewables don’t work.

And another is that energy is necessary.

... people now find it unremarkable that California and Texas would have energy shortages.

... In the case of Texas it is surely obvious why.

Despite the best efforts of the state’s promoters, when the Lone Star State is mentioned the vast majority still think “oil, that is… Texas tea” or something to that effect.

But California, whatever else it produces, also accounts for over 8% of total American crude oil extraction and over 10% of its refining.

And it is fifth among American states in per capita GDP, eight places ahead of Texas (not counting Washington, DC, whose per capita GDP is more than twice that of any state, a curious achievement by big government).

So how can it be short of energy?

You could ask New York, whose per capita GDP is second only to that of Massachusetts.

Plans to decarbonize the grid there are not going well, Francis Merton reports, and indeed seem clownishly amateur.

But it’s not funny to contemplate what a winter there might be if they somehow pull it off, or apart, and get into blackouts through some California dreaming.

To say nothing of President Biden’s vacuous but vigorous determination to do it nationwide.

As Michael Shellenberger bluntly put it, noting that energy shortages kill people during heat waves, as we add they do more generally,

 “The Real Reason They Blame Heat Deaths, Blackouts, and Forest Fires on Climate Change Is Because They’re Causing Them”, adding

“Journalists, experts, and elected officials are today blaming heat wave deaths, forest fires, and electricity shortages in New York, California, and Texas on climate change,

but the underlying cause of those events is lack of air conditioning, lack of electricity, and the failure to properly manage forests, not marginal changes to temperatures.”

Of course a blackout in the formerly Golden State, or even the collapse of the grid, doesn’t prove that climate change isn’t real.

Indeed alarmists could say told you so, it’s the exploding demand for air conditioning as summers become intolerable.

And NBC predictably did.

But however that may be, you will not persuade someone suffering under such conditions in one of the wealthiest societies the world has ever seen that the power system is working, or that it doesn’t matter that it’s not. ... "